Roof Replacement Quote Checklist
Roof quotes should not be compared only by shingle brand. Underlayment, flashing, ventilation, tear-off, disposal, sheathing, details, and warranty matter.
RightSizeTools printable worksheet
Roof Replacement Quote Checklist
Use this before roof replacement quotes or when comparing roof bids that look surprisingly different.
Project snapshot
Double-check included
- Number of tear-off layers
- Shingle type
- Underlayment
- Ice/water barrier
- Starter shingles
- Ridge cap
- Drip edge
- Flashing
- Pipe boots/vents
- Ventilation
- Sheathing repair allowance
- Disposal and cleanup
- Warranty details
Clarify before signing
- How is rotten sheathing priced?
- What flashing is replaced vs reused?
- How much ice/water barrier is included?
- Is ridge vent or ventilation work included?
- Are permits included if required?
- What workmanship warranty is provided?
Common budget surprises
- Bad sheathing
- More roof layers than expected
- Improper ventilation
- Chimney/skylight flashing
- Steep or cut-up roof access
- Accessory items omitted from a low quote
Ways to save without cutting corners
- Compare full roof systems, not just shingle price.
- Do not skip necessary flashing or ventilation.
- Avoid premium shingles unless the full system supports the upgrade.
- Schedule before emergency leak season if possible.
Quote comparison table
ItemQuote AQuote BQuote C
Roof area assumption
Tear-off layers
Shingle type
Underlayment/ice barrier
Flashing
Ventilation
Sheathing price
Disposal
Warranty
Exclusions
Helpful prep before the visit
- Take exterior photos from all sides.
- Note active leaks, stains, or prior repairs.
- Ask about attic ventilation if there are heat/moisture issues.
- Check if there are skylights, chimneys, dormers, or low-slope sections.
- Use the shingle bundle calculator for a rough material sanity check.